Review of the Enneagram Questionnaire and Methodology

Review date:

Reviewer: Dr. Carolina Estevez, Psy.D., Licensed Psychologist

Review

I reviewed the 72 questions included in the Enneagram personality test, along with the 5-point response scale and the general approach used to score and interpret the results. Overall, the questionnaire is well organized and does a great job of reflecting the main characteristics associated with each of the 9 Enneagram personality types. Most of the questions seem to fit their intended types and address relevant personality traits, emotional tendencies, motivations, and behaviors.

I believe the overall approach to scoring and interpreting the results makes sense. Using multiple questions for each personality type and allowing users to rate how closely each statement describes them provides a reasonable way to explore personality patterns. I particularly like that the test takes into account how close the highest scores are, rather than automatically assuming that the highest score identifies a user’s personality type with certainty.

I think it makes sense that some answers contribute to multiple personality types since certain characteristics can overlap. I also agree with not counting negative responses against someone when the question describes a more extreme or unhealthy behavior. I think that is a reasonable approach. Since I did not review or test the internal algorithm itself, my feedback is based on how the scoring works.

Encouraging users to read about other high-scoring types when their results are close is a good feature. It gives people an opportunity to reflect on which description fits them best instead of relying entirely on the test results.

One small change I would suggest is adjusting the language used when presenting results. Rather than stating that the test has identified someone’s type correctly, I would recommend saying that the results suggest a likely personality type. I think this is a better fit for a questionnaire that is meant to help people explore their personalities.

I think the questionnaire gives people a useful way to explore their personality traits, motivations, and behaviors. I understand that the scoring weights were adjusted based on internal analysis of user responses and feedback to improve the accuracy of the test, which is helpful. However, that alone does not establish the test’s scientific reliability or validity. Since reviewing the internal algorithm was not part of this review, I cannot comment on how accurate the weights are or how consistently the scoring identifies personality types. My review focuses on the questions, response scale, and general scoring approach described. I recommend presenting the questionnaire as a tool for personal exploration rather than a clinically validated personality assessment.

I have a very positive impression of the questionnaire. I think the questions do an excellent job of representing the different Enneagram types, and I like that the results encourage people to explore their personality rather than simply assigning them a type.

Carolina Estevez, Psy.D., Licensed Psychologist

Dr. Estevez is a licensed clinical psychologist in the State of Florida with extensive experience providing psychological services to individuals from diverse backgrounds and across all age groups. Her professional experience includes individual and group psychotherapy in inpatient and outpatient settings, community mental health centers, and substance abuse rehabilitation programs.

Throughout her career, Dr. Estevez has worked with individuals experiencing a wide range of psychological and behavioral conditions, including depression, anxiety, personality disorders, PTSD, ADHD, learning disabilities, developmental and behavioral disorders, and psychotic disorders.

She has extensive experience conducting and interpreting psychological evaluations, including personality and diagnostic assessments, educational assessments, vocational evaluations, and disability assessments.

Dr. Estevez incorporates evidence-based approaches into her clinical practice, drawing from Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), mindfulness, person-centered therapy, and positive psychology. Her approach is compassionate, supportive, and collaborative, with an emphasis on understanding each individual's unique experiences, strengths, and needs. She believes in creating a welcoming and nonjudgmental environment where individuals feel heard, understood, and empowered. Her work is guided by the belief that everyone has the capacity for personal growth, meaningful change, and improved psychological well-being.